Feature image: Canine Ethogram—Social and Agonistic Behavior, by Roger Abrantes
We have a world of knowledge to explore in our real and virtual life. However, sometimes, it is hard to find reliable evidence and facts about some subjects.
I believe there are a big misunderstanding and disinformation between an ethological definition of a species’ social behavior and a fairy tale used in dog training. Yes, the “dominance theory” belongs neither to ethology nor to any science. It was a popular pseudoscience theory created as justification for the use of coercive and violent techniques in dog training.
It is my conviction that we should use science models impartially, regardless of our moral beliefs.
Through defining terms and concepts, we become responsible professionals. We will know how to distinguish science from popular myths and allegories, and learn to respect each species. Different species communicate differently.
I have compiled a set of subject matters and research studies from authorities in animal behavior. I will update it regularly.
I expect that these articles will help you to create your educated opinion.
Give a little time to the reading of the following references. Build up a reliable scientific knowledge that will enable you to engage in meaningful discussions.
- Article from Dr. Marc Bekoff with clear definitions of “alpha,” showing that dominance in dogs exists, and the complete misunderstanding with their applications in dog training.
- Dominance, submission, hierarchies, ethograms and all scientific definitions on the subject. Article by Dr. Roger Abrantes.
- Article by Dr. Marc Bekoff with the testimony of Dr. David Mech stating that he never rejected the notion of dominance.
- Dogs display dominance. Article by Dr. Marc Bekoff with several studies and other articles on the subject.
- Article by Dr. David Mech in 2011 stating that there is no problem using the term “alpha” with wolves in some cases, that the problem was the complete misrepresentation of the term (page 8).
Agonistic Behavior Course. Use the code 4Q2V9! and get 10% discount.
Abrantes, R. (1997). The Evolution of Canine Social Behavior. Wakan Tanka Publishers.
Abrantes, R. (1997). Dog Language. Wakan Tanka Publishers
Coppinger, R. and Coppinger, L. (2001). Dogs: a Startling New Understanding of Canine Origin, Behavior and Evolution. Scribner.
Eaton, B. (2002). Dominance in Dogs: Fact or Fiction?. Dogwise.
Horowitz, A. (2014). Domestic Dog Cognition and Behavior, the Scientific Study of Canis familiaris. Springer- Verlag Berlin Heidelberg.
McFarland, D. (1998). Animal Behaviour. Benjamin Cummings. 3rd ed.
McFarland, D. (2006). A Dictionary of Animal Behaviour. Oxford University Press
Serpell, J. (2017). The Domestic Dog. Its Evolution, Behavior, and Interactions with People. Second Edition. Cambridge University Press.
Székely, T. (2010). Social Behaviour, Genes, Ecology, and Evolution. Cambridge University Press.
Watson, J.C., Arp, Robert. (2015). Critical Thinking—an introduction to reasoning well. Bloomsbury Academic.
Author’s note: Thanks to Dr. Roger Abrantes and his valuable feedback.
Last update: August 2020. Original title: “Dominance- a scientific view.”
All content of this website is protected. If you use somehow the content of this article, please give the credits using this reference: “Barata, R. (2012). Dominance in dogs: A comprehensive scientific compilation. rbarata.com.” I appreciate your professionalism.